The Norwegian Civil War in the 12th–13th Centuries as Reflected in the 'Constant Crisis' Theory
State Academic University for Humanities
For citation: Shmelev, Andrey S. The Norwegian Civil War in the 12th–13th Centuries as Reflected in the 'Constant Crisis' Theory // Graphosphaera. 2025. Vol. 5. № 1. P. 117–126. URL: http://writing.igh.ru/index.php?id=2025-5-1-117-126
DOI: 10.32608/2782-5272-2025-5-1-117-126
Abstract: This review examines a monograph by Hans Jacob Orning, professor of history at the University of Oslo, published in May 2025 (Orning H. J. Constant Crisis Deconstructing the Civil Wars in Norway, ca. 1180–1220. Ithaca, New York: Cornell University Press, 2025. (Islandica; LXVI). 276 p. ISBN: 978-0-935-99531-2 https://doi.org/10.7298/R1RJ-F850). This work offers a revolutionary approach to the study of the era of civil wars (borgerkrigstida). Orning provides a profound analysis of the sociopolitical structure of Norwegian society in the 12th and 13th centuries, challenging the traditional perception of civil wars solely as a destructive stage preceding the formation of a unified Norwegian state. By examining the social interconnections of various strata of Norwegian society, Orning not only significantly expands the chronological and territorial boundaries of the transformation of Scandinavian society but also refutes the widespread belief that the civil conflicts of that period were excessively brutal. Moreover, he convincingly demonstrates that the social conflicts of that era, far from being a sign of social ill-being, served as one of the mechanisms for regulating public life. The main conclusion of the work is that such “wars” were a characteristic feature of medieval Scandinavian society and served as an instrument of social regulation and maintaining the balance of power. To designate this special form of conflict, Orning introduces an innovative term – ‘constant crisis’, which emphasizes their specific nature.
Key words: social networks, civil war, conflict studies, ‘constant crisis’, kinship tie
Литература / References
Калдор М. Новые и старые войны. Организованное насилие в глобальную эпоху / Пер. с англ. А. Апполонова, М. Дондуковского. М.: Изд-во Института Гайдара, 2015. 416 с. [Kaldor M. Novye i starye voiny. Organizovannoe nasilie v global’nuiu epokhu (New and Old Wars. Organised Violence in a Global Era) / Per. s angl. A. Appolonova, M. Dondukovskogo. Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Instituta Gaidara, 2015. 416 s.]
Козер Л. А. Функции социального конфликта / Пер. с англ. О. А. Назаровой. М.: Идея-Пресс, 2008. 205 с. [Kozer L. A. Funktsii konflikta (Functions of Social Conflict) / Per. s angl. O. A. Nazarovoy. Moscow: Ideya-Press, 2008. 205 s.]
Соколов Е. Современность войны: Карл Клаузевиц и его теория // Философско-литературный журнал «Логос». 2019. Т. 29, № 3 (130). С. 67–98. [Sokolov Ye. Sovremennost' voyny: Karl Klauzevits i yego teoriya (Modern Warfare: Carl Clausewitz and His Theory) // Filosofsko-literaturnyy zhurnal «Logos». 2019. T. 29, № 3 (130). S. 67–98.]
Сухов А. Н. Из истории становления социальной конфликтологии // Человек: преступление и наказание. 2021. Т. 29, № 2. С. 200–209. [Sukhov A. N. Iz istorii stanovleniya sotsial'noy konfliktologii (From the History of the Formation of Social Conflictology) // Chelovek: prestupleniye i nakazaniye. 2021. T. 29, № 2. S. 200–209.]
Хохлова О. М. Общесоциологические теории и концепции исследования социального конфликта // Система ценностей современного общества. 2010. № 14. С. 300–304. [Khokhlova O. M. Obshchesotsiologicheskiye teorii i kontseptsii issledovaniya sotsial'nogo konflikta (General Sociological Theories and Concepts of Social Conflict Research) // Sistema tsennostey sovremennogo obshchestva. 2010. № 14. S. 300–304.]
Armitage D. Civil Wars: A History in Ideas. New Haven: Penguin Canada, 2017. 349 p.
Barnes J. A. Class and Committees in Norwegian Island Parish // Human relations. 1954. Vol. 7, № 1. P. 39–58.
Duby G. The Chivalrous Society. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1980. 246 p.
Evans-Pritchard E. E. The Nuer of the Southern Sudan // African Political Systems / Ed. by M. Fortes and E. Evans-Pritchard. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1940. P. 272–297.
Gersovitz M., Kriger N. What Is a Civil War? A Critical Review of Its Definition and (Econometric) Consequences // The World Bank Research Observer. 2013. Vol. 28. P. 159–190.
Gluckman M. Rituals of Rebellion in South-East Africa. Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1954. 160 p.
Gluckman M. The Peace in the Feud // Past and Present. 1955. № 8. P. 1–14.
Kaldor M. Elaborating the “New War” // Rethinking the Nature of War / Ed. I. Duyvesteyn, J. Angstrom. London; New York: Routledge, 2005. P. 215–248.
Orning H. J. Constant Crisis in Norway, 1202–1208 // New Perspectives on the ‘Civil Wars’ in Medieval Scandinavia / Ed. H. J. Orning, K. Esmark, Jón Viðar Sigurðsson. Turnhout: Brepols, 2024. P. 165–214.
Orning H. J. Constant Crisis Deconstructing the Civil Wars in Norway, ca. 1180–1220. Ithaca, New York: Cornell University Press, 2025. (Islandica; LXVI). 276 p.
Orning H. J., Vigh H. Constant Crisis // Nordic Medieval Civil Wars in a Comparative Perspective / Ed. by Jón Viðar Sigurðsson and H. J. Orning. Leiden: Brill, 2021. P. 3–34.
Поступила в редакцию / Received: 20.04.2025
Поступила после рецензирования / Revised: 17.06.2025
Принята к публикации / Accepted: 01.07.2025
